Is Mobile Learning about to become, well, simply just Learning

Over the last few years, everyone and his dog has been writing, researching and presenting their ideas on how everyone should incorporate a mobile learning strategy into their curriculum.

Obviously we are all sold on the need to move to HTML5, but the argument starts after that. The current hard sell doing the circuits is that we place our faith in a responsive style of design and development (Responsive Elearning Design) whereby we use an authoring tool that allows us to develop content that downgrades itself to match the device you are using. The key drivers for the philosophy has been that mobile students:

  • don’t have the bandwidth to download desktop based learning
  • don’t have the screen real estate to view desktop based learning
  • don’t want to view a huge 2 hour desktop course, only small chunks at convenient times
  • can’t view desktop courses on a small smartphone screen.

The problem with this approach is that everyone of the above factors has already been overcome. Yes, not in full circulation, but they have been overcome:

  • people are starting the slow adoption of 4G that will make their mobile phone access quicker than my current village broadband!
  • there are now a trickle of HD smartphones on the market. These phones have a higher screen resolution than the Logica laptop you are using to view this blog right now!
  • open source learning management systems such as Moodle are now organised in a way that they promote the creation of courses by using a series of small modular chunks of learning.
  • Screens on upmarket smartphones are slowly getting larger.

True, the above factors could still take 18 months to fully come mainstream – but in my view it won’t be long before our teenagers are all surfing the web on HD smartphones using 4G.

Simply, now, with a Moodle server and a copy of the latest Adobe Captivate, one can create multi-device learning without the need for any huge change in development.

Moodle, HTML5, Gamification and Zend

Late last year I updated my HTML5 Moodle web app so that it would work with Moodle 2.x and it’s new file system repository.

Other than that I haven’t done too much, so this year I will be aiming to improve the robustness of the system by rebuilding it using Zend/PHP rather than PHP itself.

This may take some time but will improve the behind-the-scenes structure.

I’m also going to start to see how I can use visual dashboards within Moodle to create gamificated scoreboards so young students can see whose using Moodle and it’s social features the most.

January 2012 – Mobile Learning Update

Late last year, after I had developed initial app versions for iPhone/iPad/Android devices it started to become apparent that many students have their smartphone/tablet but don’t like the idea of installing apps on them.

Therefore I have started work on a slimmed-down version of my app, that has been developed using JQuery Mobile and allows a student to access Moodle from the browser of their device.

This variant is still in its infancy, but I have included a few screenshots of where it is at the moment:

As you can see from the images, this new online only version is well on the way and it will probably become the main stay of my work for the foreseeable future, with the app variants being put to one side for now.

Mobile Learning Platform Design

For the last 3 years, the Defence Academy (DA-CMT) have been using our existing Go-le@rn mobile learning portal to provide mobile learning resources to students that are available for play-back on a wide range of mobile devices.

The existing Go-le@rn design is a simple portal that allows administrators to upload video/audio based learning resources, with students, once logged in, being allowed to download learning resources to either their mobile phone, portable media player or laptop.

Below outlines how I’m taking Go-le@rn forward, to see it integrated with a Learning Management System (LMS) so that students can choose whether they would like to take courses via a normal desktop route on the LMS or download a mobile version of the course if they’re travelling.

In short I propose to have an environment that for desktop users:

  • Contains a traditional LMS (proposing Moodle) that students can log into via their desktop/laptop/netbook and receive a standard LMS experience, take SCORM-based courses, as well as interact with other students via forums, chat sessions and instant messaging.
  • Contains an e-portfolio tool that allows students to store their own personal learning articles. These articles will demonstrate their development over the long-term and are a much better method of assessing student than simple quizzes. Mahara, the e-portfolio tool under proposal integrates with Moodle and also provides a blogging tool, social networking and a CV builder.  Users have their own personalised profiles which they can use to add employment and education history, accreditations, achievements and goals.
  • Contain a virtual world server (based around VastPark) that is fully integrated with the LMS allowing for online classroom sessions to be organised.

For smartphones (iPhone/Android/Blackberry) and iPad users the environment provides an app that:

  • Provides direct access onto the LMS so that students can carry out all the social networking functions of the system on their device.
  • Allows students to view all of the learning content within the curriculum. Content that has been ‘marked’ as for desktop use only, the app will either disable the option or provide an alternative mobile ready course in an appropriate format.

For users of MP3 audio players or Personal Media Players (PMP’s) the environment will:

  • Provide a simple login (the old Go-le@rn in effect) where students can download content to their desktop and then sideload to their device, or straight to their device if it has browser functionality (e.g. a Sony PSP). As per the current Go-le@rn, students will be invited to tell the system what device they have and then only appropriate content will be offered to the student.

A Course ‘Matrix’

At the heart of the new environment will be an add-on to Moodle which will allow administrators to define mobile alternatives to traditional desktop e-learning.

For each learning object within the LMS the administrator will be asked to provide an alternative object(s) for:

  • Tablets  (possible inclusion of iPhone) 
  • General Smartphone (e.g. iPhone / Android / Blackberry)
  • Personal Media Players (PMP)
  • MP3 Audio Players

It may be that some learning objects do not require alternatives as they run on every device, or that they may be only one alternative supplied (e.g. a podcast). The diagram below defines some of the standard media types that may be provided:

Dependant on the client there could be the need to provide services for Window-based PDA’s but for now I have left these out. The option of having up to 5 different learning objects when in the past there would only be one gives the potential for there to be quite an increase in development costs for any given course.

 

Issues around Reporting and Scorm

Given the above extra functionality whereby students will receive different learning objects depending on the device being used to view training, the reporting functionality may have to change somewhat. We will need to create a new reporting module for the LMS that:

  • Allows administrators to see for any given student, whether they have viewed a learning object offline or online.

The interesting thing to discuss here is whether we take a more relaxed view of scorm. I know this sounds preposterous but Moodle’s assessment system is far more powerful than having scorm quizzes integrated into e-learning content via Scorm. So it is my view that this is the way we should approach new content for a client using the system, have desktop learning objects that don’t have assessments within them but rely on moodle quizzes. 

This would then mean that:

  • Desktop users would see on the course list the learning object then the quiz straight afterwards
  • Mobile app users would like wise see both options after one another
  • PMP and MP3 player students would download learning objects to their devices, learn whilst on the move, but have to log into the LMS on a desktop to take a quiz

 

The mobile app in more detail

Currently there are a number of Moodle mobile apps available from the internet, some free, some not, that provide access to a Moodle LMS via the internet. The downside of these is that:

  • All of the content on the Moodle LMS must be geared towards the lowest common denominator (mobile access)
  • They are online apps, they cannot be used when offline.

The author’s intention here is to create an app that has all the functionality of the above existing apps plus:

  • Access’s the course matrix information so that mobile students see mobile content via the app instead of desktop content
  • Whilst a student is viewing content, download a copy to the device so that the student can view that content even when offline.

  

Overall System Schematic

The diagram below show how the system will operate:

 

A Closer Look

Here are some screenshots of the iPhone app in development:

Over the next few months I’ll be providing regular updates on how the platform is progressing.

M-Learning Case Study: Go-le@rn Mobile Learning Portal

In 2007 a pure research project that made it into the real military world was the concept of using soldiers own mobile devices to deliver learning.

Soldier’s tend to be even more technology minded than the normal ‘man on the street’. When away from home they have their favourite media player or mobile and keep care of them. Even in land rovers or warrior armoured personal carriers, you will see crewmen modify their vehicles to hold their iPods nice and safe. So why not try and use those devices as a delivery platform for learning. A platform that aims to provide content that will work on the widest range of mobile devices possible.

From 2007-2010 our in-house developed Mobile Learning Portal allowed military students to download video and audio based learning resources to their mobile device whether it may be a mobile phone, Ipod or other MP4/MP3 player.

Access to the portal was available either through your desktop or via your mobile phone. Actually my favourite device for access was a Sony PSP via my home wifi!

Early on we identified the need for the portal to have a ‘critical mass’ of learning content, as without that students would not come back if all they saw was one or two bits of learning. The client agreed and using a number of bespoke content suppliers as well as off-the-shelf products, we were able to host nearly 300 mobile courses, mostly in MP3/MP4 format.

Since its roll-out within the MoD, the portal has been quite successful and has an established small loyal user base.

Mobile learning that co-exists with your desktop curriculum

I’m currently in the latter stages developing a series of apps that allow a student to view content from a moodle-based LMS. I know, not knew, but I’ve also modified our moodle database so that for every desktop resource, there are equivalent smartphone/tablet courses available.

Therefore, if a person views our Moodle LMS from their desktop, they get the ‘standard’ desktop course, yet if they access from their iPad/iPhone, they get a differing version tailored for that device.

Other features, such as chat/forums/quizes are then handled on the apps as well to provide a socially rich experience.

I’m very interested on people’s views as to whether my splitting of courseware in this fashion is a good idea, or whether you’ve tried and succeeded in having e-learning that displays well on every device.